| 1 | Ladainian Tomlinson, RB (SDC, 9) | Adrian Peterson, RB (MIN, 8) | Steven Jackson, RB (STL, 5) | Brian Westbrook, RB (PHI, 7) | Joseph Addai, RB (IND, 4) | Tom Brady, QB (NEP, 4) | Randy Moss, WR (NEP, 4) | Marion Barber, RB (DAL, 10) | Frank Gore, RB (SFO, 9) | Larry Johnson, RB (KCC, 6) | 1 |
| 2 | Braylon Edwards, WR (CLE, 5) | Terrell Owens, WR (DAL, 10) | Willis McGahee, RB (BAL, 10) | Peyton Manning, QB (IND, 4) | Maurice Jones-Drew, RB (JAX, 7) | Reggie Wayne, WR (IND, 4) | Reggie Bush, RB (NOS, 9) | Ryan Grant, RB (GBP, 8) | Marshawn Lynch, RB (BUF, 6) | Clinton Portis, RB (WAS, 10) | 2 |
| 3 | Larry Fitzgerald, WR (ARI, 7) | Brandon Jacobs, RB (NYG, 4) | Marques Colston, WR (NOS, 9) | Steve Smith, WR (CAR, 9) | Tony Romo, QB (DAL, 10) | Antonio Gates, TE (SDC, 9) | Andre Johnson, WR (HOU, 8) | T.J. Houshmandzadeh, WR (CIN, 8) | Plaxico Burress, WR (NYG, 4) | Drew Brees, QB (NOS, 9) | 3 |
| 4 | Michael Turner, RB (ATL, 7) | Anquan Boldin, WR (ARI, 7) | Roy Williams, WR (DET, 4) | Julius Jones, RB (SEA, 4) | Brandon Marshall, WR (DEN, 8) | Darren McFadden, RB (OAK, 5) | Laurence Maroney, RB (NEP, 4) | Jamal Lewis, RB (CLE, 5) | Chad Johnson, WR (CIN, 8) | Torry Holt, WR (STL, 5) | 4 |
| 5 | Ben Roethlisberger, QB (PIT, 6) | Derek Anderson, QB (CLE, 5) | Jonathan Stewart, RB (CAR, 9) | Rudi Johnson, RB (CIN, 8) | Wes Welker, WR (NEP, 4) | Selvin Young, RB (DEN, 8) | Willie Parker, RB (PIT, 6) | Edgerrin James, RB (ARI, 7) | Earnest Graham, RB (TBB, 10) | Fred Taylor, RB (JAX, 7) | 5 |
| 6 | Lee Evans, WR (BUF, 6) | Kellen Winslow, TE (CLE, 5) | Santonio Holmes, WR (PIT, 6) | Calvin Johnson, WR (DET, 4) | Jason Witten, TE (DAL, 10) | Greg Jennings, WR (GBP, 8) | Rashard Mendenhall, RB (PIT, 6) | Marvin Harrison, WR (IND, 4) | Kevin Smith, RB (DET, 4) | Ronnie Brown, RB (MIA, 4) | 6 |
| 7 | Matt Forte, RB (CHI, 8) | Chester Taylor, RB (MIN, 8) | Thomas Jones, RB (NYJ, 5) | LenDale White, RB (TEN, 6) | DeAngelo Williams, RB (CAR, 9) | Ricky Williams, RB (MIA, 4) | Carson Palmer, QB (CIN, 8) | Dwayne Bowe, WR (KCC, 6) | Matt Hasselbeck, QB (SEA, 4) | Chris Chambers, WR (SDC, 9) | 7 |
| 8 | Chris Cooley, TE (WAS, 10) | Felix Jones, RB (DAL, 10) | Donovan McNabb, QB (PHI, 7) | Tony Gonzalez, TE (KCC, 6) | Laveranues Coles, WR (NYJ, 5) | Justin Fargas, RB (OAK, 5) | Donald Driver, WR (GBP, 8) | Kevin Curtis, WR (PHI, 7) | Roddy White, WR (ATL, 7) | Dallas Clark, TE (IND, 4) | 8 |
| 9 | Chris Johnson, RB (TEN, 6) | Joey Galloway, WR (TBB, 10) | Nate Burleson, WR (SEA, 4) | Bernard Berrian, WR (MIN, 8) | Javon Walker, WR (OAK, 5) | Hines Ward, WR (PIT, 6) | D.J. Hackett, WR (CAR, 9) | Vincent Jackson, WR (SDC, 9) | Heath Miller, TE (PIT, 6) | Minnesota Vikings, DST (MIN, 8) | 9 |
| 10 | Jerricho Cotchery, WR (NYJ, 5) | Deion Branch, WR (SEA, 4) | Matt Schaub, QB (HOU, 8) | Jerry Porter, WR (JAX, 7) | Ryan Torain, RB (DEN, 8) | Anthony Gonzalez, WR (IND, 4) | Alge Crumpler, TE (TEN, 6) | Deuce McAllister, RB (NOS, 9) | Patrick Crayton, WR (DAL, 10) | Eli Manning, QB (NYG, 4) | 10 |
| 11 | David Garrard, QB (JAX, 7) | Reggie Brown, WR (PHI, 7) | Laurent Robinson, WR (ATL, 7) | Jay Cutler, QB (DEN, 8) | New York Giants, DST (NYG, 4) | Ahman Green, RB (HOU, 8) | San Diego Chargers, DST (SDC, 9) | Marc Bulger, QB (STL, 5) | Santana Moss, WR (WAS, 10) | Donte' Stallworth, WR (CLE, 5) | 11 |
| 12 | Dallas Cowboys, DST (DAL, 10) | Green Bay Packers, DST (GBP, 8) | New England Patriots, DST (NEP, 4) | Baltimore Ravens, DST (BAL, 10) | Nate Kaeding, K (SDC, 9) | Adam Vinatieri, K (IND, 4) | Nick Folk, K (DAL, 10) | Jeremy Shockey, TE (NYG, 4) | Stephen Gostkowski, K (NEP, 4) | Derrick Mason, WR (BAL, 10) | 12 |
| 13 | Josh Brown, K (STL, 5) | Matt Stover, K (BAL, 10) | Todd Heap, TE (BAL, 10) | Rob Bironas, K (TEN, 6) | Vince Young, QB (TEN, 6) | Pittsburgh Steelers, DST (PIT, 6) | Sammy Morris, RB (NEP, 4) | Mason Crosby, K (GBP, 8) | San Francisco 49ers, DST (SFO, 9) | Shayne Graham, K (CIN, 8) | 13 |
| 14 | Jerious Norwood, RB (ATL, 7) | Philip Rivers, QB (SDC, 9) | Josh Scobee, K (JAX, 7) | Ted Ginn Jr., WR (MIA, 4) | Sidney Rice, WR (MIN, 8) | Jake Delhomme, QB (CAR, 9) | Jon Kitna, QB (DET, 4) | Jacksonville Jaguars, DST (JAX, 7) | Aaron Rodgers, QB (GBP, 8) | Reggie Williams, WR (JAX, 7) | 14 |